Neighborhood pub burger
Brunson’s Pub
A Payne Avenue pub on the East Side of St. Paul doing one of the best straightforward bar burgers in the metro. Smashed-style on a soft bun, no overengineering, draft list that goes deep on local. The kind of room where you arrive at six and leave at ten.
Modern American with serious burger
Citizen Supper Club
A St. Paul restaurant whose burger has quietly become one of the most-talked-about in the metro. Dry-aged blend, soft brioche, perfect cheese melt, almost annoyingly good fries. Order it at the bar with a martini.
Cult burger in one of the smallest rooms in town
Gus Gus
Anna Morgan and Kevin Manley, who met working at 112 Eatery, run this tiny bistro out of the first floor of an apartment building, and the burger has a cult following to match the living-room feel. The fries are taken so seriously there is a dedicated potato chef. Small room, big burger.
The Irvine Park Burger, in an 1870 mansion
Forepaugh’s
The grand Victorian mansion in Irvine Park, dating to 1870, reopened in 2024 with a reimagined bar where the draw is the Irvine Park Burger, a blend of Wagyu, brisket, and chuck. White-tablecloth history with a serious burger at the bar.